Ep. 105: Las triquiñuelas del mal (Evil's little tricks)
Rip-off: House
Summary: A team of diagnosticians, led by the anti-social yet brilliant Dr. Gregory House, attempt to diagnose and cure medical mysteries. House himself is known for his lack of a bedside manner, believing that "everybody lies," and he goes to great lengths to avoid interacting with his patients. To say that House is arrogant is an understatement, but his brilliance allows him to get away with it. He is also known to engage the service of prostitutes and is addicted to Vicodin, which he takes to help with the pain from the infarction in his right leg. Although his friends say that he was misanthropic prior to the infarction, I personally think that his substance abuse has only exacerbated his extreme personality.
LHdP spin: Deker's character description lists him as having a disposition similar to House. Like House, Deker is talented and has been described as a womanizer who is known for being sarcastic and irreverent. However, unlike House, his sarcasm and irreverence masks the fact that he does empathize with the suffering of others.
Epic fail: Deker doesn't work as a House rip-off, partly because unlike House, Deker is all about protocol. In the subsequent episodes, he wants to inform Mariano about the inscriptions on his back and he was hesitant to cut the third victim open - both reasons were based on his belief that protocol should be followed. House is the complete opposite when it comes to protocol. He takes a differential method to his diagnosis, where his treatment of patients are based on a process of elimination. Based on this method, House often butts heads with his superiors, because he wants to perform medical procedures that he feels are necessary (and they feel are unnecessary) to diagnose and cure his patients. It is this unorthodox method of treatment, and his success with it, that allows House to be as arrogant as he is. Additionally, while House is known for being crude and mocking people, he often does so based on observations of their personality and appearance. Deker is good at his job - there's no denying that he is a competent forensics inspector. However, in Deker's very first scene, his complete disrespect for Silvia's domain and her work when he knows nothing about her just makes him seem like an asshole. And as I've stated before, the audience (and the hombres) have yet to learn why Deker is the way that he is, so it's hard to write off his arrogant behavior like the audience can do with House. Moreover, House's comments might be crude, but they are also funny and true. I don't care how much Deker uses sarcasm to mask his supposed empathy. I find it hard to believe that he's being empathetic at all when DL informs him that Silvia died on her wedding day from a bullet wound which she tried to operate on herself and his response is "Unsuccessfully, I see." Again, that just makes him come off like a douche.
Rip-off: Serpico
Summary: Frank Serpico is a NYC police officer whom many of his fellow officers refuse to work with because he doesn't participate in extorting money from local criminals. While Serpico starts off as a beat cop, he later transitions into working on undercover assignments and changes his appearance to blend in with the hippie generation of the '70s, including growing out his hair and beard.LHdP spin: Pove took on somewhat of a Frank Serpico makeover in this episode. Mainly, he grew out his beard in an attempt to "blend in" as a tough cop that the newbies would respect.
Rip-off: Se7en
Summary: Two homicide detectives search for a serial killer, who chooses his victims because they represent examples of the seven deadly sins. The killer is motivated by the fact that people are not dedicated to working on being virtuous. Their sinful acts make them evil, and thus, the killer believes they can only be saved by acts of contrition.LHdP spin: The show's take is actually a reverse rip-off. The serial killer behind the "66.6" storyline is choosing his victims because they represent examples of the seven virtues - charity, justice and soberness thus far. Additionally, the killer (who I suppose is the devil himself) appears to be motivated by a desire to eliminate the good in the world so that evil can prevail.
kalike
*The title for this lecture is based on the song "Bullet in the Head" by Rage Against the Machine

8 comments:
Awesome summary, KC! Can't wait for the next episode ripoffs. Thank you very much!
TOTALLY awsome lecture.
Very nice analysis, I enjoyed reading it. I disagree, however, in your assessment that Decker is just a douche. His comment regarding Silvia’s death punctuates his strange relationship with death. He has become desensitized, talking about it as if he were talking about the weather. What comes across as being insensitive is, in my opinion, a defense mechanism he’s developed due to... we have yet to find out.
great post. I actually dont mind the Decker/House character. I'm sure his back story will come to light in time. What really is just shit about this season is the whole 666 / backwards 7 rip off. its just so... easy... and lame. :/
I've sadly become totally apathetic to this show (all but the pepa bits that is) after discovering it only 2.5 months ago. I loved it intensly from the second i came across "the silvia and pove coffe scene" not just the Pepsi bits but the whole loony package. now its just so... lame.
Im so glad the Uni is here for all the old clips! :)
Anonymous-
Thanks for your comments and insight. I should've clarified that Deker comes off as a "just a douche" mainly b/c the audience doesn't know his backstory yet. I've admitted that I liked him better in these last two episodes, because I think we are beginning to see why he's developed a defense mechanism.
I suppose I also should've clarified that I'm trying to an analysis of each episode instead of the show as a whole, which is why I limited my analysis of him to this ep. I think it's quite possible that this rip-off can be turned around, but based off of the first ep., I saw it as a failure.
I've edited the post accordingly so again, thanks.
See, my whole problem is that I DON'T CARE what Deker's backstory is! House is a million times more entertaining and witty, and his backstory was slowly unfolded in a way that made us understand where's coming from, but not necessarily empathize.
The writers of House never held up some tragedy in his past and pointed to that as the reason why he's a douche and that we should feel sorry for him because of it. No, he's had some shitty things happen to him, but when it comes down to it, he's just an asshole. Figuring people out is more important to him than the person themself. And that's what makes him interesting. I'm sorry, but LHDP just can't handle such a complex character...and I just don't know that the writers are even talented enough to pull a House-like character off even if the show did afford the right framework for it.
I'm pretty sure Deker's sob story is going to be that he lost a loved one because LS already confirmed the he and Pepa are alike...and she also basically confirmed they're going to hook up.
As much as I actually do like the actor, I just can't bring myself to give two shits about this douche (whatever his reason or being a douche may be)...especially when I let my sentimentality take over and see him as "The Silvia Replacement" - taking her job and her wife.
No me gusta.
The writers of House never held up some tragedy in his past and pointed to that as the reason why he's a douche and that we should feel sorry for him because of it. No, he's had some shitty things happen to him, but when it comes down to it, he's just an asshole.
Yes, exactly. House is the anti-hero. That's the way his character's been constructed, and we are never deceived about it. That's why it works. And Hugh Laurie is a brilliant beyond brilliant actor, and I'm sorry, but Benjamin Vicuna couldn't possibly compete.
Moreover, House isn't set up as a replacement for an adorable character that had been loved by fans for EIGHT SEASONS, so even if House is a douche, the audience can't hate him -- at worst they can be apathetic toward him. However convincing Deker's backstory might have been (and of course it wasn't, ultimately), he was never going to be able to replace Silvia in the hearts and minds of fans, and given that he was damned to begin with, the writers should have made him more respectful of Silvia's lab space.
Finally, what I found even more outrageous (apart from the fact that Pepa sleeps with the Silvia-replacement character -- I mean, really, LHdP writers? You couldn't have had her sleep with another character? Someone who wasn't a forensic scientist?) was the number of times Pepa lets him get away with being disrespectful of Silvia's space or disrespectful of her relationship with Silvia (I mean he called her a heterosexual! It's quite clear that Silvia comes out as bisexual on the show ... and bisexual with a preference for women, emotionally). In that post-coital scene with Deker, it would have been so much more satisfying if Pepa had either yelled at him or decked him or gotten up and left the room in disgust after he called Silvia heterosexual.
I found it just not credible that any doctor trash talk a DEAD colleague. House insults that other doctor constantly but they are friends and he is alive for fuck' s sake. But see, that was ALEX Pina insulting Marian Aguilera. Why? Because she left? Or maybe because she refused to sleep with him? What gives? And the possesed nun telling DL, your daughter that bitch! What is the reason for that, unsettle D.L. or insult Marian Aguilera? Deker I just don' t like any of the new characters. I don' t like the season, waste of time totally, and I tried, but is another show alltogether.
Post a Comment